How to compare performance between Nginx and Apache?

Chris Worner

Well-known member
Registered
Joined
Apr 15, 2016
Messages
612
Points
28
My websites are running on both Nginx and Apache server but I don't know which one is giving better performance for my websites. Is there a way or tool to check performance of Nginx and Apache to compare?
 

David Beroff

Well-known member
Registered
Joined
Jun 14, 2016
Messages
1,498
Points
63
You can run same website on both web server and checking your website speed with gtmatrix or pingdom to see which is giving better speed, from that result you can know Nginx or Apache is giving better performance for your website. Just a way :)
 

harry_v

Well-known member
Registered
Hosting Provider
Joined
Dec 20, 2017
Messages
110
Points
18
My websites are running on both Nginx and Apache server but I don't know which one is giving better performance for my websites. Is there a way or tool to check performance of Nginx and Apache to compare?

Hello Chris Worner,

If you're looking to compare the performance of Nginx and Apache, there are a few things you'll need to consider. First, you'll need to consider the type of application you're running. If you're running a static website, Nginx will likely outperform Apache. However, Apache might perform better if you're running a dynamic website or application. Second, you'll need to consider your server's hardware. If running on older or lower-end hardware, Nginx may again outperform Apache. However, Apache will likely perform better if you're running on newer or higher-end hardware.

Nginx & Apache can be tuned for better performance, but the specifications will vary depending on your server's setup. You'll need to experiment with different configurations to find what works best for your application and server environment. Finally, you'll need to consider your server's configuration. To compare the performance of Nginx and Apache, we will use the open-source benchmarking tool JMeter as It simulates user traffic and measures the response time of the web server.

When it comes to web server performance, Nginx is known for its low response times. As a result, it's often the go-to choice for high-traffic sites needing to serve up content quickly. Apache, on the other hand, is not as fast out of the box. But with some tuning, it can match or even exceed Nginx's performance. Request Handling When it comes to request handling, Nginx and Apache are both capable of serving a large number of requests concurrently.

However, Nginx can do so with fewer resources. It means that Nginx can handle more traffic with the same amount of resources as Apache. Memory Usage in Nginx tends to use less memory than Apache. It is because Nginx uses an event-based model, while Apache uses a process-based model. The event-based model is more efficient when it comes to memory usage because it doesn't spawn new processes for each request.

Ultimately, it comes to the user's requirements and preferences to choose between these two Web servers. Thus I hope the information above helps you to compare the performance between Nginx and Apache Web Servers.

---------------------------
Regards,
harry_v
 

Kaz Wolfe

Well-known member
Registered
Joined
Jul 7, 2016
Messages
609
Points
28
Yes, there are several tools and techniques that you can use to compare the performance of Nginx and Apache servers running your websites. Here are some options:

Load testing tools: You can use a load testing tool like Apache JMeter, Siege, or Gatling to simulate a high volume of traffic to your websites and measure the performance of Nginx and Apache servers under load. You can compare metrics like response time, throughput, and error rates to determine which server is performing better.

Apache JMeter: You can use Apache JMeter to create a test plan that simulates a high volume of traffic to your websites, and then run the test plan to measure the performance of Nginx and Apache servers under load. Here's an example command to run a JMeter test plan from the command line:
Code:
jmeter -n -t testplan.jmx -l results.jtl
This command runs a JMeter test plan stored in the file "testplan.jmx" and saves the test results to the file "results.jtl". You can then use JMeter's GUI or a tool like JMeterPluginsCMD to generate graphs and reports from the test results.

Siege: You can use Siege to perform a load test on your websites and compare the performance of Nginx and Apache servers. Here's an example command to run Siege with 100 concurrent users for 30 seconds:

Code:
siege -c 100 -t 30s http://yourwebsite.com
This command sends requests to your website using 100 concurrent users for 30 seconds and reports the results, including the number of successful and failed requests, the response time, and the throughput.

Benchmarking tools: There are several benchmarking tools available that allow you to compare the performance of Nginx and Apache servers using a variety of metrics, such as requests per second, CPU usage, and memory usage. Some popular benchmarking tools include ApacheBench, wrk, and Siege.

ApacheBench: You can use ApacheBench to benchmark the performance of Nginx and Apache servers using a simple HTTP request. Here's an example command to run ApacheBench with 100 requests and 10 concurrent users:

Code:
ab -n 100 -c 10 http://yourwebsite.com
This command sends 100 requests to your website using 10 concurrent users and reports the results, including the requests per second, the time per request, and the transfer rate.
wrk: You can use wrk to benchmark the performance of Nginx and Apache servers using a customizable HTTP request. Here's an example command to run wrk with 100 connections and 10 threads for 10 seconds:

Code:
wrk -c 100 -t 10 -d 10s http://yourwebsite.com
This command sends requests to your website using 100 connections and 10 threads for 10 seconds and reports the results, including the requests per second, the average latency, and the maximum and minimum latencies.

Web server logs: You can use the access logs generated by Nginx and Apache servers to analyze the performance of your websites. You can compare metrics like response time, request processing time, and server error rates to determine which server is performing better.

Nginx access log: You can enable Nginx access logging by adding the following line to your Nginx configuration file:

Code:
access_log /var/log/nginx/access.log combined;
This line logs all HTTP requests to the file "/var/log/nginx/access.log" using the "combined" log format, which includes the request method, URL, response status, and other information. You can then analyze the log file using a tool like AWStats or GoAccess to compare the performance of Nginx and Apache servers.

Apache access log: You can enable Apache access logging by adding the following line to your Apache configuration file:
Code:
CustomLog /var/log/apache/access.log combined
This line logs all HTTP requests to the file "/var/log/apache/access.log" using the "combined" log format, which is similar to Nginx's "combined" log format. You can then analyze the log file using a tool like AWStats or GoAccess to compare the performance of Nginx and Apache servers.


Monitoring tools: There are several monitoring tools available that allow you to track the performance of Nginx and Apache servers in real-time. These tools can help you identify performance issues and optimize your server configurations. Some popular monitoring tools include Prometheus, Grafana, and Nagios.

Prometheus: You can use Prometheus to collect and visualize metrics from Nginx and Apache servers in real-time. You can install the Prometheus server on a separate machine and configure it to scrape metrics from Nginx and Apache servers using their respective exporters. Here's an example configuration file for the Nginx exporter:

Code:
scrape_configs:
- job_name: 'nginx'
static_configs:
- targets: ['nginx-server:9113']
This configuration file tells Prometheus to scrape metrics from the Nginx exporter running on the host "nginx-server" on port 9113. You can then use the Prometheus UI or a tool like Grafana to create dashboards and alerts based on the collected metrics, such as the number of active connections, the request rate, and the response time.

Apache exporter: You can use the Apache exporter to collect and expose metrics from Apache servers to Prometheus. Here's an example command to run the Apache exporter with a custom endpoint:

Code:
apache_exporter -scrape_uri http://localhost/server-status?auto
This command runs the Apache exporter and exposes the metrics on the endpoint "http://localhost:9117/metrics". You can then configure Prometheus to scrape the metrics from the exporter using a similar configuration file as the one for Nginx.

By using these tools and techniques, you can get a better understanding of the performance of Nginx and Apache servers running your websites, and make informed decisions on how to optimize your web server setup for maximum performance and reliability.

It's worth noting that the performance of Nginx and Apache servers can depend on a variety of factors, such as the size and complexity of your websites, the type of content being served, the hardware and network infrastructure, and the server configuration. Therefore, it's important to use multiple tools and techniques to get a comprehensive view of server performance and to optimize your server configurations accordingly.
 
Latest Threads
Replies
0
Views
122
Replies
1
Views
77
Recommended Threads

Latest Hosting OffersNew Reviews

Sponsors

Tag Cloud

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

Top